Rules

Eligibility

The competition is open to anyone 18 years or older who is currently attending college, or who graduated from college since May 2007. Teamwork across disciplines, backgrounds and ages is encouraged. One entry per person or team is allowed. Students are not allowed to be on more than one team, but students are allowed to submit a project with one team and additionally submit one individual project.

As part of the online submission form, each participant or team member will be required to provide proof of eligibility. Any one of the following is acceptable as proof of eligibility:

DEFINITION OF "ELECTRONIC WASTE": For the purposes of this contest, electronic waste (e-waste) includes the following items: computers (desktops and laptops), scanners, printers, cell phones, PDAs, optical drives, televisions, DVD/VCR players, MP3 players, computer monitors, video game consoles, computer peripherals (keyboards, mice, cables), zip drives, and fax machines.

E-waste excludes: refrigerators, toasters, radios, alarm clocks, electronic devices that are a part of a motor vehicle, display devices contained within appliances, such as a clothes washer or dryer, oven range, etc.

Categories

E-Waste Prevention Category

Electronic components focusing on the elimination or reduction of e-waste through life-cycle considerations. An entry in the E-waste Prevention category must focus on decreasing the amount of e-waste generation. The entries in this category should focus on new products or services.

See "Judging Criteria, E-Waste Prevention Category" for more details.

E-Waste Reuse Category

Focuses on the aesthetic and technical reuse of e-waste into useful electronic and non-electronic products. An entry in the E-waste Reuse category must reuse old e-waste components in order to create a new product.

See "Judging Criteria, E-Waste Reuse Category" for more details.

Judging Criteria

E-Waste Prevention Category

  • Design Solution
    The design must not only be visually appealing but be purposeful in its form factor and highly usable by the intended users.

  • Innovation
    What is the big idea relating to green computing technology? How profound is the idea and how innovative is the solution from a green computing technology product design perspective? The entries in this category should focus on new products or services.

  • Green Computing Technology Considerations
    How well did the design solution address various green computing technology considerations?

  • Feasibility and Concept Validation
    How realistic is it? Can it be manufactured in the near term or long term under green manufacturing constraints? Did the entrant do a sufficient amount of investigation regarding what is possible from a functional and manufacturing perspective? Are the research sources cited, varied, and valid? Did the entrant provide proper citations and credit for research and intellectual property referenced?

  • Prevention
    How effective is the design solution at preventing the generation of e-waste? An entry in the e-waste prevention category must focus on decreasing the amount of e-waste generation.

  • Utilization of Green Assessment Tools
    Did the entrant make good use of assessment tools such as Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and other green validation and product development process tools that provide guidelines and standards for current thinking and current regulation for environmental product designs and manufacturing?

  • Documentation of Process and Methodology
    How well has the entrant captured the process of creating the final design solution?

  • Presentation
    Has the entrant effectively presented the concept? Has the entrant made effective use of visualization tools? How well did the entrant communicate the ideas and solution using text, animation and imagery? How well did the entrant make use of media to express ideas?

E-Waste Reuse Category

  • Design Solution
    The design must not only be visually appealing but be purposeful in its form factor and highly usable by the intended users.

  • Innovation
    What is the big idea relating to reuse of electronic waste materials? How profound is the idea and how innovative is the solution from a green design perspective?

  • Feasibility and Concept Validation
    How realistic is it? Can it be marketed in the near term or long term under green manufacturing constraints? Did the entrant do a sufficient amount of investigation regarding what is possible from a collection and fabrication perspective? Are the research sources cited, varied and valid? Did the entrant provide proper citations and credit for research and intellectual property referenced?

  • Innovative Use of Components
    How innovative is the use and implementation of the e-waste components? Is there a demonstrated reuse of existing components and parts? An entry in the e-waste prevention category must reuse old e-waste components in order to create a new product.

  • Documentation of Process and Methodology
    How well has the entrant captured the process of creating the final design solution?

  • Presentation
    Has the entrant effectively presented the concept? Has the entrant made effective use of visualization tools? How well did the entrant communicate the ideas and solution using text, animation and imagery? How well did the entrant make use of media to express ideas?

 

Registration

Registration is free. Participants can register as individuals or as teams as long as the team has no more than 5 members. Entrants need to register for the competition between January 4 and May 9, 2011. Competition registration closes at 4:59pm Central Time on May 9, 2011.There will be no opportunity for early or late registration.

Online Submission Form

Each submission team must complete the online submission form that includes team and contact information, as well as a list of e-waste and new components used. A project description (500 words maximum) must also be included on the online submission form.

Proof of Eligibility

As part of the online submission form, each participant or team member will be required to provide proof of eligibility. Any one of the following is acceptable as proof of eligibility:

Bibliography

An optional bibliography of references consulted in the preparation of the design project and/or cited in the project description may be uploaded in PDF format. There is no limit on the number of references that may be cited. Although the bibliography is optional, it should be noted that the provision of resources cited and credit for research and intellectual property referenced is considered when judging entries (see Judging Criteria for both E-waste Prevention and E-waste Reuse categories).

"Video Commercial" Submission

Participants should create an original video composition that serves as a commercial for their product, highlighting its design, features, and special design concepts. The video should NOT be a plain description of the project or a narrative description of the project.

The video should be uploaded to YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/) and should be listed as “Unlisted (anyone with the link can view).” After the competition results are announced, the video can be made public by the entrants. Please be advised that making your video unlisted protects your anonymity during the judging process, and helps to ensure that your design ideas are protected from potential competitors while registration remains open, however it is up to you to guard the link to your video—in other words, you are advised to share the link to your video only with your team mates and the judges via the online submission form. An “unlisted” video is not entirely private; it might still appear elsewhere on the web if anyone who knows the video’s URL shares it. ISTC, SEI, the University of Illinois, its affiliates and competition sponsors are not responsible for infringement upon your intellectual property if the link to your video is shared beyond your team and the judges and competition administrators via the online submission form. See http://www.google.com/support/youtube/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=181547 for more information on “unlisted” videos. The link to your video will be entered on your online submission form.

The following actions are REQUIREMENTS for your video upload. Failure to comply with these requirements will result in disqualification from the competition.

If you experience a technical difficulty with uploading the link to your YouTube video from the online submission form, please contact Joy Scrogum via e-mail immediately. Some teams have experienced an issue despite having a valid link to a YouTube video and making that video embeddable, etc. as outlined above and despite re-trying to submit the video URL. In these instances, as long as you have contacted Joy Scrogum about the difficulty prior to the competition deadline, and it is clear that you attempted to upload your video but failed (contest coordinators will be able to tell from the online submission form), you can submit the link to your YouTube video as part of the optional bibliography. Put the link to your video on YouTube at the top of the bibliography and label it as the link to your video commercial. If your entry is not disqualified for any other reason, jurors will be instructed to look for the link to your video within the bibliography and to not penalize your project for this. You MUST attempt to upload your video into the "YouTube URL" field on the online submission form first and you MUST contact Joy Scrogum about the technical difficulty. This note only pertains to people who have successfully uploaded their video to YouTube, have a valid YouTube URL, yet still experience some technical difficulty with uploading that YouTube URL to the online submission form. Please be advised that competition organizers can not do anything to alter the rules of conduct as outlined on YouTube. For example, if your video is not able to be viewed in certain countries or unable to be uploaded to YouTube because it violates copyright laws, that is not something the competition organizers can help you with. You must adhere to the terms of service as stated on the YouTube web site, and upload your video to YouTube.

Note that the online submission form can be accessed and revised by entrants from the competition web site until the registration deadline; after the deadline passes, you will no longer be able to access or modify your submission.

Agreements

Participation in this competition constitutes your full and unconditional agreement to and acceptance of these official rules and the decisions of the event organizer, which are final and binding. Winning a prize is contingent upon fulfilling all requirements set forth herein. The event organizer reserves the right to disqualify any entry, at any time, for any violation of the official rules.

Content

By participating in the competition, entrants agree that their submissions, including but not limited to, any uploads, text, links, communications, software, images, sounds, data or other information, will not contain any content that is unlawful, harmful, threatening, abusive, harassing, defamatory, libelous, invasive of another's privacy, vulgar, profane, sexually explicit, obscene, racially or ethnically offensive or otherwise objectionable, including but not limited to entries that:

Organizer Rights

Entrants will retain ownership of their entry, including all intellectual property rights that may exist in the entry. The event organizers shall not acquire any right, title or ownership interest in any entry. However, by submitting an entry, the event organizers are granted the unconditional and perpetual right, license, and consent to reproduce, encode, store, copy, transmit, publish, post, broadcast, display, and exhibit the entry in any media throughout the world in relation to the competition, without limitation, and without additional review, compensation, or approval from the entrant or any other party. The event organizers shall have the right, but not the obligation, to use the name, likeness, biography and other information of entrants.

Verification

The event organizer reserves the right to independently verify the originality and ownership of the entry and to validate that the entry does not violate the proprietary rights of any third party.